This family-run pizza shop has kept residents of Waterford and nearby New London supplied with the tastiest pizzas since 1979. You won’t get anything fancy at Supreme Pizza, but that’s part of the appeal. Grab a counter stool and take your pick from the dazzling array of overstuffed grinders, piping hot pizza pies, and bubbling baked pasta dishes. The prices are reasonable, the service is friendly, and the portions are generous, so you’re guaranteed to leave satisfied.