In 1961, following a customer request, the Animal Style burger was born. So popular was the option, which featured two mustard-cooked beef patties, lettuce, tomato, extra spread and grilled onions, it made its way onto In-N-Out’s now famous ‘Secret Menu’ and remains there today. Other items on that menu include Animal Style fries, Neapolitan milkshakes, a Protein Style burger (a patty wrapped in lettuce instead of served in a bread bun) and the indulgent 4x4, with its four patties and four slices of cheese.