Britain's worst savings accounts!


Updated on 18 September 2009 | 9 Comments

With the base rate stuck at 0.5%, times are tough for savers. Even so, these 60 savings accounts are a disgrace and savers should scarper at once!

In my view, the past twelve months have been the worst in history for savers. Last September, when the Bank of England's base rate stood at 5%, it was possible to find best buy savings accounts paying the thick end of 6% a year.

The great rate slump

In response to the growing financial crisis, the Bank of England took an axe to its base rate, cutting it six times in a row between October 2008 and March 2009. For six months, the base rate has stuck firmly at 0.5% and shows no signs of going anywhere until 2010 at the earliest.

Of course, when the Bank lowers its base rate, savings providers rush to follow suit. Hence, over the past year, savings interest rates have collapsed to levels not seen for generations. In fact, with the base rate at a 315-year low, we could have the lowest savings rates seen since the founding of the Bank in 1694.

Savers are being swindled

To show you how bad things have become for British savers, I asked lovemoney.com partner Moneyfacts, to find me the UK's lowest-paying savings accounts. At first, I asked for a list of all savings accounts paying a gross rate (before tax) of 0.25% a year or less on a balance of £1,000.

Alas, this produced an unwieldy list of 307 poor-paying accounts, so I had to lower the bar. In order to chop my dataset down to size, I removed 247 accounts paying gross interest rates of between 0.1% and 0.25% a year. Although these are awful accounts, there are even worse offenders.

This left me with 60 accounts, all of which pay less than 0.1% a year before tax on a balance of £1,000. To put this into context, a rate of 0.1% on £1,000 comes to one measly quid in interest per year. After savings tax of 20%, this drops to just 80p (or 60p for higher-rate taxpayers).

Now it's time to reveal the ten lowest-paying savings accounts in the UK. The remaining 50 are shown in a second table at the end of the article:

The ten most shocking savings accounts

(all pay under 0.1% a year on a balance of £1,000)

Provider

Account name

Rate (%)

Notice

Bank of China (UK)

30 Day Notice Deposit

0

30 days

Bank of China (UK)

7 Day Notice Deposit

0

7 days

Cumberland BS

Cashcard Flexible Account Issue 2

0

Instant

Laiki Bank

Instant Access

0

Instant

Bank of Ireland (GB)

Card Saver

0.001

Instant

Bank of Ireland (GB)

Telephone Saver

0.001

Instant

Chesham BS

Bonus Saver

0.01

Instant

Newcastle BS

Nova Plus Issue 3

0.01

Instant

Newcastle BS

Nova Star 10

0.01

15 months

Progressive BS

Investment Share

0.01

Instant

As you can see, the four accounts at the top of our list pay no interest whatsoever on a balance of £1,000. Frankly, that's a disgrace - and begs the question whether they can honestly be called savings accounts at all.

The remaining 56 accounts pay yearly rates of between 0.001% (that's 1p a year on £1,000) to 0.075%. Most of these accounts give you instant access to your money, in some cases via a passbook or cash card. Even so, this is no excuse for paying such paltry rates of interest, as the best easy-access accounts put the above accounts to shame.

What I find breath-taking is that some of these accounts add insult to injury by restricting your access to your cash. For example, Bank of China (UK)'s 30 Day Notice Deposit account pays no interest and yet you have to give 30 days' notice to withdraw your money. This is sheer madness!

I'm going to let one provider from this Hall of Shame off the hook, because it is a special case. Triodos Bank - shown in the table below - is an ethical provider which supports charities and sustainable businesses. Hence, savers put their money with Triodos for moral reasons without worrying so much about interest rates.

On the other hand, all the other banks and building societies above deserve a big slap from their savers. What particularly disappoints me is that building societies feature so prominently in my tables. The building-society movement has been the traditional home for our savings since Victorian times. It saddens me to see so many awful accounts being promoted by these organisations.

What should savers do?

When you take tax and inflation (rising prices) into account, the cash inside these accounts is worth less with every passing day. Alas, there's no doubt in my mind that billions of pounds could be rotting away in these poor-paying accounts.

Of course, there's absolutely no point in staying loyal to one provider if it's costing you a sizeable sum each year. Therefore, my advice to savers is simple: it's time to ditch and switch. By shopping around for a new savings account, you could earn a table-topping rate of 3% or more - and enjoy easy access, too.

For instance with the current market-leader - Citibank Flexible Issue Saver 6 - you'll earn a rate of 3.30% and you can make withdrawals whenever you like. So, don't delay -- shop around and switch today!

50 more shocking savings accounts

Provider

Account name

Rate (%)

Notice

Ulster Bank

Easy Access Savings

0.01

Instant

Cheltenham & Gloucester

Cheltenham Gold

0.04

Instant

Cheltenham & Gloucester

Direct Transfer

0.04

No notice

Cheltenham & Gloucester

The London

0.04

No notice

Cambridge BS

Instant Sapphire

0.05

Instant

Cheltenham & Gloucester

Branch 10

0.05

Instant

Darlington BS

Instant Access

0.05

Instant

Darlington BS

Sentinel 30

0.05

30 days

Derbyshire BS

Derbyshire Cash A/c

0.05

Instant

Dudley BS

Flexi Saver

0.05

Instant

Dudley BS

Save and Sponsor

0.05

7 days

Dudley BS

Special Savings

0.05

28 days

First Direct

Savings

0.05

No notice

First Trust Bank (NI)

Select Savings

0.05

Instant

Hinckley & Rugby BS

High Rise

0.05

Instant

Hoare & Co

Deposit

0.05

Instant

HSBC

Flexible Saver

(Non Bank Account Plus Customers)

0.05

Instant

Intelligent Finance

Direct Access Savings

0.05

No notice

Leeds BS

Capital 7

0.05

7 days

Manchester BS

Premier Instant

0.05

Instant

Progressive BS

Premium Return

0.05

Instant

Saffron BS

Cashbuild

0.05

Instant

Stroud & Swindon BS

30 Day Notice Saver

0.05

30 days

Triodos Bank

Charity Saver - Amnesty International

0.05

33 days

Triodos Bank

Charity Saver - Fairtrade Foundation

0.05

33 days

Triodos Bank

Charity Saver - Friends of the Earth Trust

0.05

33 days

Triodos Bank

Charity Saver - Housing Justice

0.05

33 days

Triodos Bank

Charity Saver - Medical Foundation

0.05

33 days

Triodos Bank

Charity Saver - Quaker Housing Trust

0.05

33 days

Triodos Bank

Charity Saver - Soil Association

0.05

33 days

Triodos Bank

Charity Saver - Somerset & Dorset Wildlife

0.05

33 days

Triodos Bank

Charity Saver - Western Buddhist Order

0.05

33 days

Triodos Bank

Charity Saver -

World Development Movement Trust

0.05

33 days

Triodos Bank

Triodos Saver

0.05

90 days

Triodos Bank

Triodos Saver

0.05

33 days

Triodos Bank

Triodos Saver

0.05

1 Year

Ulster Bank

U First Savings

0.05

Instant

West Bromwich BS

Albion Premier

0.05

Instant

West Bromwich BS

Amber Blue Saver

0.05

Instant

West Bromwich BS

Blues Super Saver

0.05

Instant

West Bromwich BS

Century Saver

0.05

Instant

West Bromwich BS

Community

0.05

Instant

West Bromwich BS

Direct Easy Access

0.05

No notice

West Bromwich BS

Oak

0.05

Instant

West Bromwich BS

Premium Share

0.05

Instant

West Bromwich BS

Saddlers Savers

0.05

Instant

West Bromwich BS

Severn Valley Saver

0.05

Instant

Whiteaway Laidlaw Bank

Instant Access Savings

0.05

Instant

Yorkshire BS

Cash Transactor

0.05

Instant

Turkish Bank (UK)

Basic Savings

0.075

Instant

Compare savings accounts at lovemoney.com.

More: Switch your savings account today | Protect your savings from inflation | Five money-making tips for the over-50s

Comments


Be the first to comment

Do you want to comment on this article? You need to be signed in for this feature

Copyright © lovefood.com All rights reserved.